jepoyskieLOVEbianca Posted March 2, 2013 Share Posted March 2, 2013 sa tingin ko mahirap talagang sabihin kung sino mas magaling sa kanila... different era kasi eh... pero sinusubukan kong mag-imagine, what if naglaro sila ng one-on-one... (hindi yung sitwasyon ngayon ha, matanda na si Bird eh...) Bird and LBJ both on their prime... pag inimagine ko, parang iiwan-iwanan lang ni James si Bird eh...kasi kung skills lang ang pag-uusapan, mas marami na talagang kayang gawin yung LBJ kesa kay Bird... opinion lang po ah.. Quote Link to comment
dfgvan Posted March 4, 2013 Author Share Posted March 4, 2013 its unfair to compare players from different generations, but its leadership over skills... larry bird wins by a mile.... by LBJ is slowly getting there uhm sir from the first page and also from the thread subtitle... wag nating iconsider yung intangibles...skill set lang ang pagbasehan natin kung sino ang mas magaling... sa tingin ko mahirap talagang sabihin kung sino mas magaling sa kanila... different era kasi eh... pero sinusubukan kong mag-imagine, what if naglaro sila ng one-on-one... (hindi yung sitwasyon ngayon ha, matanda na si Bird eh...) Bird and LBJ both on their prime... pag inimagine ko, parang iiwan-iwanan lang ni James si Bird eh...kasi kung skills lang ang pag-uusapan, mas marami na talagang kayang gawin yung LBJ kesa kay Bird... opinion lang po ah.. sir, based on the criterion set on the first page can you make a score and see who scores higher based on skill sets. Quote Link to comment
alberto_ Posted March 5, 2013 Share Posted March 5, 2013 Scoring- LBJPassing- tieRebounding- BirdPerimeter Quarterbacking-LBJInterior Control- Bird (Defense- LBJ (Bird played the passing lanes but was'nt exactly lockdown guy) 1 Quote Link to comment
jepoyskieLOVEbianca Posted March 8, 2013 Share Posted March 8, 2013 uhm sir from the first page and also from the thread subtitle... wag nating iconsider yung intangibles...skill set lang ang pagbasehan natin kung sino ang mas magaling... sir, based on the criterion set on the first page can you make a score and see who scores higher based on skill sets. IMHO bossing ha... Shooting: Bird (although nag-iimprove na din unti-unti si LBJ)Ball Handling: LBJ (kaya nga nakakapag-PG sya, saka hindi ka naman makakapasok sa luob kung wala nito)Rebounding: LBJ (siguro malaking bagay din yung athleticism sa rebounding, maganda kumuha ng posisyon si LBJ)Passing (Not limited to assists): Bird, medyo mas magaling humanap ng kakampi si Bird kesa kay LBJSteals: LBJ (base lang sa mga napanuod kong games ni Bird and James ha)Blocks: LBJ malupit mga block ni LBJ eh... hindi ko tinitignan kung gano kadami ha, tinignan ko kung panu sumusupalpal at nagdedepensaOff Ball Movement: LBJ, obvious naman, kaya madalas makakuha ng Alley-oop eh...On Ball Defense: Tie siguro, hindi din matatawaran ang depensa ni Bird eh...Off Ball Defense: Bird, kitang kita kung paano pinahirapan ni Bird mga binabantayan nya, kahit wla pa hawak na bola...Slashing: LBJ 9laking bagay yung athleticism nya eh)Post Up: Bird, parang hindi masyado mahilig sa post up si LBJ, although sa tingin ko, kung susubukan nya, kaya namanPhysicality/Strength: LBJ, (gamit na gamit nya kasi yung built ng katawan nya sa maraming bagay sa luob ng court)Jumping: LBJ (no need to explain)Dunking LBJ (no need to explain) ayun po! if you looked at it differently, no need to argue po... just stating how i see things Quote Link to comment
mountainclimber Posted March 15, 2014 Share Posted March 15, 2014 larry bird..anytime of the day... Quote Link to comment
jjpaler Posted June 3, 2014 Share Posted June 3, 2014 Shooting -BIRDBall Handling -LBJRebounding -LBJPassing (Not limited to assists) -BIRDSteals -LBJBlocks -LBJOff Ball Movement -LBJOn Ball Defense -LBJOff Ball Defense -LBJSlashing -LBJPost Up -LBJPhysicality/Strength -LBJJumping -LBJDunking -LBJ loyalty -BIRD LBJ wins via wide margin..:)How come Bird doesn't have a monicker? Quote Link to comment
bughaw1 Posted June 3, 2014 Share Posted June 3, 2014 Shooting -BIRDBall Handling -LBJRebounding -LBJPassing (Not limited to assists) -BIRDSteals -LBJBlocks -LBJOff Ball Movement -LBJOn Ball Defense -LBJOff Ball Defense -LBJSlashing -LBJPost Up -LBJPhysicality/Strength -LBJJumping -LBJDunking -LBJ loyalty -BIRD LBJ wins via wide margin..:)How come Bird doesn't have a monicker?merun sir...the hick from french lick. because of culture differences kaya hindi gamit sa pinas yung monicker niya. quality of opposition-bird..no offense lalamunin ng buhay si lbj if nung 80s siya naglaro. lbj has the tendency to fade especially if naghahabol yung team niya. wala pa siya sa level ni bird.he will get there though. injury prone c bird eh while healthy most of the time c lbj. Quote Link to comment
akita Posted June 4, 2014 Share Posted June 4, 2014 Larry Legend for me. just a personal preference. Quote Link to comment
leo01 Posted June 18, 2014 Share Posted June 18, 2014 Larry Legend for me too. Not much physical gifts but still a force to reckon with. Quote Link to comment
moli_calingasan Posted June 19, 2014 Share Posted June 19, 2014 LARRY BIRD ALL THE WAY... james is an arrogant player.. Quote Link to comment
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.